Signs an element has failed
- Hot water runs out quickly, then turns lukewarm.
- Water never gets as hot as it used to.
- The breaker trips whenever the heater runs.
- Water is cold even though the breaker is on.
- A strange sizzling sound comes from the tank when it heats.
One bad element leaves the other working, which is why the heater still makes some hot water. If both fail, you get nothing.
How to test an element
- 1
Cut the power
Turn off the breaker for the heater and confirm with a voltage tester that the wires are dead.
- 2
Open the access panel
Remove the cover and the insulation to see the thermostat and the element terminals.
- 3
Disconnect the wires
Note where each wire goes, or take a photo.
- 4
Test with a multimeter
Set the meter to resistance. A good element reads a low, steady value. A reading of infinity means a burned-out element.
- 5
Check the thermostat
A failed thermostat can look like a failed element, so test both before buying parts.
Replacing the element
Turn off the cold supply, attach a hose to the drain valve and drain the tank below the level of the element you are replacing. Unscrew the old element with an element wrench, and remove it. Clean the gasket seat, fit the new element with a new gasket, and tighten it.
Refill the tank with the hot tap open so air escapes, and do not turn the power on until the tank is full. A dry element burns out in seconds. This is the step people skip, and it is the most common reason a new element fails on day one.
Sediment, scale and your water
Elements fail faster in a tank full of scale, and scale comes from minerals in the water. We do not state a hardness figure for Bridgeton, because we did not find one on a primary source for the city's supply. Ask your water provider for its annual water quality report, and look at the crust on your faucet aerators for a clue.
Water heater work is governed by New Jersey's plumbing subcode (N.J.A.C. 5:23-3.15), and the element circuit follows the National Electrical Code (NEC).
If the aerators are crusted, flush the heater once a year, which removes sediment before it buries the lower element. Older Bridgeton houses often have heaters in basements with floor drains that no longer work, so a leak during a flush can flood the floor. Keep the hose run to a working drain or a bucket, and check the discharge before you start.
The same flush-and-check routine applies to heaters in Vineland, where the city's water comes from wells, and in Millville, where you should ask your own provider for a quality report.
Element replacement versus a new heater
| Situation | Better choice |
|---|---|
| Heater under about ten years, tank sound | Replace the element |
| Heater past ten years with rust at the base | Consider replacement |
| Tank is leaking | Replace the heater |
| Both elements and a thermostat have failed | Weigh the repair cost against a new unit |
An element costs far less than a new heater. A heater with sediment-coated elements or a rusted tank is on borrowed time, so ask the plumber for an honest opinion. Our water heater repair page covers the other common failures.
What affects the cost of an element replacement
- The part. Elements come in different wattages and styles, and they are not interchangeable.
- Labor. Draining, replacing and refilling take time.
- Related parts. A thermostat or relief valve may need replacing too.
- Sediment. A tank full of scale takes longer to drain and may need flushing.
- Hour of the call. After-hours dispatch can be priced differently.
We give you a clear price before work starts. For a number on your heater, call (856) 250-1784.
Choosing the right replacement element
Elements are sold by wattage, voltage, shape and mounting style. Match the wattage and voltage printed on your heater's data plate, and check whether the element screws in or bolts on with a flange. Using a higher wattage than the heater is rated for is a fire risk.
Low-density elements spread the heat over a larger surface and tend to resist scale better than standard ones. They cost a little more. In a house where you know the water leaves deposits, the extra cost can pay back in element life.
After the repair: what to watch
Give the tank time to heat fully, then check the water at a tap. If the water is still lukewarm, the thermostat or the other element may be the problem. Make sure the access panels and insulation are back in place and the cover is secure.
Keep an eye on the relief valve and the base of the tank for moisture over the next few days. A heater that has been opened can reveal other weak points, such as a seeping drain valve.
Safety and when not to do it yourself
Water heaters combine household voltage with water, so shut off the breaker and test the wires before touching anything. If you are unsure whether the power is off, stop. If the heater is gas-fired, it has no electric element, and the problem is a burner, pilot or thermocouple.
A professional also checks the relief valve and the discharge pipe during an element job, which are safety items most homeowners forget.
Questions about this topic in Bridgeton
A failed upper element often means little or no hot water. A failed lower element means water runs out sooner. Testing both with a meter confirms which.
No. The element sits inside the tank, so you must drain below its level first.
Often several years, and sediment shortens that. A flush once a year helps.
Like-for-like parts replacement is generally maintenance. Ask the Bridgeton construction office if you are changing the unit.
It was almost certainly powered on before the tank was full. Always fill the tank completely and open a hot tap first.
If you are not comfortable with household wiring and draining a tank, yes. Element and thermostat replacement is routine work for a plumber.
Heater not heating?
Call to book a diagnosis.
